The Schwab wrote:Is it just me or is there someone obviously missing from this list?
The Schwab wrote:That's what I was thinking, senior of the year and not on the list? Surprise
The Schwab wrote:That's what I was thinking, senior of the year and not on the list? Surprise
#10 wrote:The Schwab wrote:That's what I was thinking, senior of the year and not on the list? Surprise
What are Rosenau's stats compared to those who made it?
ibhun10 wrote:#10 wrote:The Schwab wrote:That's what I was thinking, senior of the year and not on the list? Surprise
What are Rosenau's stats compared to those who made it?
Can I ask a serious question - is this all about stats???? Or, should they vote for the BEST Players. The best players don't always put up huge numbers. (I don't think I need to clarify)
And I agree with Packers 21 - I doubt any of the players left off care -
ibhun10 wrote:#10 wrote:The Schwab wrote:That's what I was thinking, senior of the year and not on the list? Surprise
What are Rosenau's stats compared to those who made it?
Can I ask a serious question - is this all about stats???? Or, should they vote for the BEST Players. The best players don't always put up huge numbers. (I don't think I need to clarify)
And I agree with Packers 21 - I doubt any of the players left off care -
#10 wrote:ibhun10 wrote:#10 wrote:The Schwab wrote:That's what I was thinking, senior of the year and not on the list? Surprise
What are Rosenau's stats compared to those who made it?
Can I ask a serious question - is this all about stats???? Or, should they vote for the BEST Players. The best players don't always put up huge numbers. (I don't think I need to clarify)
And I agree with Packers 21 - I doubt any of the players left off care -
No argument from me, about the BEST players not always putting up the huge numbers. But this is for this season, and all the sports writers have to go on is stats. So if the athlete's team did not make it to state, how are the sportswriters able to make comparisons another way.
packers21 wrote:Im ok with nobody from Grafton you can defintely argue for Brooke Gaustad on the second team, but those girls were a great team not individually led. Kinda like Buelah this year, no boys on the All-State team. I doubt any of them care either.
wolves65 wrote:the hardest part about reading girls basketball is there is a much bigger talent gap from the top teams to the bottoms compared to the boys B and A squads. You have alot of girls playing on good teams that get maybe 2 quarters so they don't have the stats and they get penalized for that fact. Also no girls team deserves 2 girls on this roster. Pick one and move on because if a girls team has two all-staters in class B they should dominate and neither beach or Central Valley could be considered dominate teams. That is just lazy media work. Your MVP and Senior Player of the year don't make it is a bit of a head scratcher. You can't say anything about any the kids on any of these teams because they had nothing to do with the process.
VOTCC wrote:I will say this much, Fallyn Freije is a good player, but head to head versus Emily Thompson this year, it wasn't a comparison, Thompson dominated her twice. Carrington players didn't have point stats because they play on a team loaded with scorers. Leading scorer this year was Becca Scherr. Not trying to take away from any kid who made these teams, but if you play on an average or bad team & have big stats doesn't mean your an all-state player. Unfortunately, the people who vote or decide don't see hardly any of these kids play, & that's sad they get to vote on these awards. Rosenau led Cgtn. in rebounding & assists just about every game to go along with a 12ppg. ave. Scherr led Cgtn with 14 ppg & also led the team in steals most nights & if it wasn't her it was Rosenau. Thompson should have been 1st team, Rosenau definitely belongs & Scherr is right there. JMO, some with say sour grapes, so be it, but I've watched way more kids than any voter did.
wolves65 wrote:Wallenda- saw them play 2 of the games they lost so that was enough. Would take grafton ahead in a heartbeat. There ok bit both all state, not this year. How many did you see.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests