magic man wrote:Is there ever any consideration put into how many sports there are during a given season, that could take away from the numbers for a particular program?
.
GoTheDistance wrote:magic man wrote:Is there ever any consideration put into how many sports there are during a given season, that could take away from the numbers for a particular program?
.
Good point. A very talented cross country runner (he placed high at state) didn't play football this year (last year he did both). This has to affect programs in other schools. Not sure how they would add a stipulation for that. Maybe most schools have both?
The Schwab wrote:d_fense wrote:The Schwab wrote:Or if you want more categories:
0-10 multiply by 1.5
11-20 multiply by 1.25
21-30 multiply by 1
31-40 multiply by .75
41+ multiply by .5
So, what you are really saying is, if 100% of families is a district are average, (not free or reduced but not above average income) we should multiply their number by 1.5????? I thought your issue was with schools that had more high income families because of their perceived advantages.
The advantages that Shiloh has are not perceived, they are actual advantages.
magic man wrote:GoTheDistance wrote:magic man wrote:Is there ever any consideration put into how many sports there are during a given season, that could take away from the numbers for a particular program?
.
Good point. A very talented cross country runner (he placed high at state) didn't play football this year (last year he did both). This has to affect programs in other schools. Not sure how they would add a stipulation for that. Maybe most schools have both?
I know that some of the "advantaged" private schools in Fargo, have several fall sports: Tennis, Football, Cross Country, & Soccer.. And when you're dealing with private schools, the pool is smaller to choose from.
I look at some of these numbers listed for the schools, and then look at their football rosters. If they are true, then some have a football turnout of around 95%.. (For example: listed with 60 boys, and 50 on their roster).
Flip wrote:how many foreign exchange students are some schools getting? Doesn't seem like that would make much difference.
magic man wrote:Flip wrote:how many foreign exchange students are some schools getting? Doesn't seem like that would make much difference.
I would guess those numbers are higher at private schools vs public, and I would estimate it would be close to the number of free and reduced lunch kids.
The Schwab wrote:magic man wrote:Flip wrote:how many foreign exchange students are some schools getting? Doesn't seem like that would make much difference.
I would guess those numbers are higher at private schools vs public, and I would estimate it would be close to the number of free and reduced lunch kids.
Please don't compare foreign exchange students to free and reduced meal students.
The Schwab wrote:magic man wrote:Flip wrote:how many foreign exchange students are some schools getting? Doesn't seem like that would make much difference.
I would guess those numbers are higher at private schools vs public, and I would estimate it would be close to the number of free and reduced lunch kids.
Please don't compare foreign exchange students to free and reduced meal students.
Gunning4ya wrote:The Schwab wrote:magic man wrote:Flip wrote:how many foreign exchange students are some schools getting? Doesn't seem like that would make much difference.
I would guess those numbers are higher at private schools vs public, and I would estimate it would be close to the number of free and reduced lunch kids.
Please don't compare foreign exchange students to free and reduced meal students.
The foreign exchange program does not allow kids to attend private schools. There is a student that is living with a family that has their children in a private but the exchange student has to attend the public program.
Gunning4ya wrote:The Schwab wrote:magic man wrote:Flip wrote:how many foreign exchange students are some schools getting? Doesn't seem like that would make much difference.
I would guess those numbers are higher at private schools vs public, and I would estimate it would be close to the number of free and reduced lunch kids.
Please don't compare foreign exchange students to free and reduced meal students.
The foreign exchange program does not allow kids to attend private schools. There is a student that is living with a family that has their children in a private but the exchange student has to attend the public program.
The Schwab wrote:Even if they are allowed to have foreign exchange students...I've only seen foreign exchange students that are in 11 or 12th grade, they wouldn't factor in to the 7-10 enrollment number. I'm sure if they would be a sophomore or younger the NDHSAA wouldn't make you count them.
madseason wrote: And if you are a private school you can not be 9 man. IMO
magic man wrote:madseason wrote: And if you are a private school you can not be 9 man. IMO
What is the basis for this line of thinking?
Exactly!!NodakQ2 wrote:magic man wrote:madseason wrote: And if you are a private school you can not be 9 man. IMO
What is the basis for this line of thinking?
Because if you can recruit 9, you should be able to recruit 11 without any problem.
bulldog_power wrote:I see posts about private schools recuriting all the time. I hope Everyone does realize that private schools
Have to follow the same exact rules as public schools. Including eligibility rules. The ndhsaa places all schools private and public in divisions based on enrollment, provided by DPI. If a schools enrollment places them in A division whether that's AAA or 9man why isn't that fair. There doesn't seem to be a more fair way to place schools. I don't like it when a private school comes and beats my team, but I don't automatically look at them and think they recruit because I don't think they are that much better than other teams we play. Maybe its the wrong thinking but I just assume if they were all recuriting they would win more
Howie wrote:I'm not sure, but I have a feeling that a public high school would get in trouble if "friends of said school" were "loaning" a kid money to pay their immigration fees to enter the US.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests