BasketballMind wrote:Bison-Vikes #1 wrote:No enrollment cutoffs. AA - 9 largest schools in each defined region. A - 6 largest schools in each defined region. B - the rest. Numbers evaluated every 2 years.
It seems thought out and I like that you brought an actual proposal. My only issue with it is that we're basically turning the "Big B" schools into one conference with two divisions. Takes away from the atmosphere of the actual State B tournament in my opinion. I'll take a look at Region 1 and 2 right now as they'd make up most of the NE division.
HCV, Thompson, MPCG, Grafton, Central Cass, Kindred, Northern Cass, Oak Grove, Hatton-Northwood, Park River are all out of the old R1 and R2. Cavalier is right on the border of that.
Now it's Enderlin laughing their way to the State tournament as the top 3 teams in their region are gone. North Border demolishes everyone in their path as 5/8 teams from the R2 tournament are now gone.
In a true class b shouldn't they be (Enderlin/North Border)? It has always been that way. A group of athletes making their run and then might not happen in that school for another 15 years. Right now you can predict 90% of the teams going for the next 10 years and it's always the same ones.
The remaining "B" schools are still going to need to become better programs because most of their best competition is gone.
They should try to get better. But at least there is a chance to make the dance which should entice them to get better. Right now, there really isn't any chance in maybe 6 of the 8 regions.
That's what this is about. Improving participation. That has to be the main goal. Not winning a state tournament. If it's only about winning, go to 1 class and see how it works.
It's either going to be either average teams "winning state" or a team like Enderlin with a few studs from the same family will destroy everyone. I don't think I'm going to a region tournament that has 7 teams in it with one of them being worth my time to watch. Going to the state "B" wouldn't be a big deal the way it is now and the attendance would plummet.
100% disagree. Enderlin, North Border, EKM, North Star, Flasher, Our Redeemers, Bowman County, Powers Lake could have all been there this year. I would be willing to bet this proposed tourney would have better attendance than current field.
You'd also start to see the random "Open Enroll" after a few years from the newer "A" schools to "B" schools. Or you'd have a stud from a "B" school on a bad team move to an "A" school that was near him/her/
You will always see that no matter what system is in place.