Page 1 of 1

Mr. Basketball Finalists?

PostPosted: Mon Feb 19, 2018 12:37 pm
by CentralCity
Who are the top candidates in Class B Basketball?

Region 1- Andrew Christianson, Fargo Oak Grove
Region 3- Garrett Bickett, Carrington
Region 4- Kyler Mcgillis, St. Johns
Region 6- Anthony Vetter, Bishop Ryan
Region 7- Isaiah Kludt, Hettinger
Region 8- Wyatt Hanson, Stanley

This would be my list.

Re: Mr. Basketball Finalists?

PostPosted: Tue Feb 20, 2018 2:40 pm
by ReadyToPlay
Region 2 Dalton Albrecht, Grafton, but maybe not as he is only a junior...

Re: Mr. Basketball Finalists?

PostPosted: Tue Feb 20, 2018 2:53 pm
by spins
there are quite a few others i would pick in region 6 over vetter.

Does it need to be a senior?

Re: Mr. Basketball Finalists?

PostPosted: Tue Feb 20, 2018 4:12 pm
by The Schwab
Not sure how many candidates there will be, but I see a few names on that list that I think would be pretty good candidates.

Re: Mr. Basketball Finalists?

PostPosted: Tue Feb 20, 2018 11:41 pm
by NodakQ2
The Schwab wrote:Not sure how many candidates there will be, but I see a few names on that list that I think would be pretty good candidates.


Key words: “a few names”...Others are All State Candidates, but not Mr. B.

Re: Mr. Basketball Finalists?

PostPosted: Tue Feb 20, 2018 11:49 pm
by Run4Fun2009
NodakQ2 wrote:
The Schwab wrote:Not sure how many candidates there will be, but I see a few names on that list that I think would be pretty good candidates.


Key words: “a few names”...Others are All State Candidates, but not Mr. B.


Class A will occupy 2-4 spots for finalists as well...as it is a State-wide award not just a 'B' award.

Re: Mr. Basketball Finalists?

PostPosted: Tue Feb 20, 2018 11:53 pm
by Flip
ReadyToPlay wrote:Region 2 Dalton Albrecht, Grafton, but maybe not as he is only a junior...

you should post more, you seem to really know basketball.

Re: Mr. Basketball Finalists?

PostPosted: Wed Feb 21, 2018 8:02 am
by NodakQ2
Run4Fun2009 wrote:
NodakQ2 wrote:
The Schwab wrote:Not sure how many candidates there will be, but I see a few names on that list that I think would be pretty good candidates.


Key words: “a few names”...Others are All State Candidates, but not Mr. B.


Class A will occupy 2-4 spots for finalists as well...as it is a State-wide award not just a 'B' award.


That’s what I was getting at Run. My point was that I’d be surprised to see more than two names on this list on the Mr. B finalist list.

Re: Mr. Basketball Finalists?

PostPosted: Wed Feb 21, 2018 8:28 am
by OldSchoolBaller
I think Class B might get 3 this year. I'm thinking McGillis and Hanson for sure and then Christianson will probably beat out Kludt because of Fargo Media.

Re: Mr. Basketball Finalists?

PostPosted: Wed Feb 21, 2018 10:54 am
by The Schwab
OldSchoolBaller wrote:I think Class B might get 3 this year. I'm thinking McGillis and Hanson for sure and then Christianson will probably beat out Kludt because of Fargo Media.


Honestly I think it will depend on which of those teams gets to the state tournament. If 3 of their teams make it to state and one doesn't that one will probably be the odd man out (unless it's Wyatt Hanson, then we could possibly have 4 class B candidates) that's my educated guess but I'm probably way off.

Re: Mr. Basketball Finalists?

PostPosted: Wed Feb 21, 2018 11:14 am
by OldSchoolBaller
The Schwab wrote:
OldSchoolBaller wrote:I think Class B might get 3 this year. I'm thinking McGillis and Hanson for sure and then Christianson will probably beat out Kludt because of Fargo Media.


Honestly I think it will depend on which of those teams gets to the state tournament. If 3 of their teams make it to state and one doesn't that one will probably be the odd man out (unless it's Wyatt Hanson, then we could possibly have 4 class B candidates) that's my educated guess but I'm probably way off.

Good Point. When are the finalists picked though? Is it before or after the State B Tournament field is set?

Re: Mr. Basketball Finalists?

PostPosted: Wed Feb 21, 2018 11:30 am
by OldSchoolBaller
scc wrote:
OldSchoolBaller wrote:I think Class B might get 3 this year. I'm thinking McGillis and Hanson for sure and then Christianson will probably beat out Kludt because of Fargo Media.

"Fargo Media" accounts for a maximum of four votes. https://ndapssa.com/index.cfm?page=members

You also have Mayville with 2 and Valley City with 1 which are fairly close. Then you have Grand Forks with 3 which is also pretty close, and Region 2 or Grand Forks Area will probably not have a representative. Either way a kid from Fargo is going to get more media exposure than a kid from Hettinger for Mr. Basketball. That is not to say one is more deserving than the other, that is just the way that it is. You also have to remember that Christianson had a pretty good State Tournament last year, and the whole state got to see him on the big stage for 3 games.

Re: Mr. Basketball Finalists?

PostPosted: Wed Feb 21, 2018 2:22 pm
by CentralCity
IMO Class B will get 3, maybe four candidates. What I should have said is "Who I think is good enough to be a Mr. Basketball candidate" I do not think all will be Mr. Basketball candidates, but they are all good enough. (Just my opinion)

Re: Mr. Basketball Finalists?

PostPosted: Wed Feb 21, 2018 2:37 pm
by winner-within
Generally Speaking? its all about stats

Re: Mr. Basketball Finalists?

PostPosted: Wed Feb 21, 2018 11:31 pm
by joew
Anyone who has watched region 7 ball can't put Kludt on that list. Great athlete and good kid but against a strong Beulah Defense he was held to very few points. Beulah has 3 or 4 comparable kids. Christianson put up somewhere around 30 points against that same defense plus contributing in other ways. Hanson, Well he is just a outstanding athlete and deserves a strong look.

Re: Mr. Basketball Finalists?

PostPosted: Thu Feb 22, 2018 11:15 am
by Howie
Beulah has 3 or 4 comparable kids? No, they don't. Ferebee would be the only one on the level of Kludt. I would be willing to bet against Beulah Kludt was close to a triple double this year. There were 2 juniors on last years all-state team, Hanson and Kludt. There are good players across the state, please don't come on here and try to say that there are 3 or 4 kids from Beulah on the same level as Kludt. I bet if you asked Region 7 coaches to pick one kid to have on their team, Isaiah Kludt would be an answer by many.

Re: Mr. Basketball Finalists?

PostPosted: Thu Feb 22, 2018 3:41 pm
by balla45
Simply my personal opinion.

Of the players named, the only ones who I feel should be Mr. Basketball candidates are Wyatt Hanson and possibly Kyler McGillis. I have not had the chance to see McGillis play live, but from what I hear, he is in the upper echelon talent wise. No hate intended on anyone, but just obvious to me that Hanson is significantly better than the rest who I have seen, as are other players such as Josh Sipes, Joe Pistorius, Trae Steckler, or Jake Kava. I think everyone named is a good player, but just as an example, and not to pick on Andrew Christianson in particular, but I do not think he is a top 5 player in Fargo/West Fargo right now, so I would struggle to give him that honor when I feel there are a handful of players in his own area who are better high school basketball players.

Just my personal opinion. I do think all players are fun to watch and are talented, just feel that the talent gap between some is fairly large.

Re: Mr. Basketball Finalists?

PostPosted: Thu Feb 22, 2018 4:07 pm
by winner-within
balla45 wrote:Simply my personal opinion.

Of the players named, the only ones who I feel should be Mr. Basketball candidates are Wyatt Hanson and possibly Kyler McGillis. I have not had the chance to see McGillis play live, but from what I hear, he is in the upper echelon talent wise. No hate intended on anyone, but just obvious to me that Hanson is significantly better than the rest who I have seen, as are other players such as Josh Sipes, Joe Pistorius, Trae Steckler, or Jake Kava. I think everyone named is a good player, but just as an example, and not to pick on Andrew Christianson in particular, but I do not think he is a top 5 player in Fargo/West Fargo right now, so I would struggle to give him that honor when I feel there are a handful of players in his own area who are better high school basketball players.

Just my personal opinion. I do think all players are fun to watch and are talented, just feel that the talent gap between some is fairly large.


I agree and like you say no disrespect....I've seen McGillis 2 times once as a Jr. and then again this year early in the season and he is complete....he is as complete or greater of a player than many many Mr. Basketball winners of the past....I saw Wyatt H. play the whole State tourney last year and was very impressed......definitely 2 different styles though.........they would be my top 2 from class B

Re: Mr. Basketball Finalists?

PostPosted: Thu Feb 22, 2018 4:30 pm
by NodakQ2
balla45 wrote:Simply my personal opinion.

Of the players named, the only ones who I feel should be Mr. Basketball candidates are Wyatt Hanson and possibly Kyler McGillis. I have not had the chance to see McGillis play live, but from what I hear, he is in the upper echelon talent wise. No hate intended on anyone, but just obvious to me that Hanson is significantly better than the rest who I have seen, as are other players such as Josh Sipes, Joe Pistorius, Trae Steckler, or Jake Kava. I think everyone named is a good player, but just as an example, and not to pick on Andrew Christianson in particular, but I do not think he is a top 5 player in Fargo/West Fargo right now, so I would struggle to give him that honor when I feel there are a handful of players in his own area who are better high school basketball players.

Just my personal opinion. I do think all players are fun to watch and are talented, just feel that the talent gap between some is fairly large.


AGREE 100%...Well said...My sentiments exactly.

Re: Mr. Basketball Finalists?

PostPosted: Thu Feb 22, 2018 9:11 pm
by joew
Wasn't trying to make anyone mad. I said Kludt was a good player and would be a asset to any team. Playing Beulah he had 12 points 7rebounds. Ferebee Had 26 points 11 rebounds. Every games is different. I would put Ferebee ahead of Kludt but not in the same class as Hanson