packers21 wrote:I think Rugby needs some more representation.
packers21 wrote:I think Rugby needs some more representation.
Run4Fun2009 wrote:packers21 wrote:I think Rugby needs some more representation.
Is it because they got 3 players named from a senior-laden team? Richland also has 3 players honored.
Alternates will dress one of the nights (if from the east...likely the night in Fargo; vice versa for west players).
packers21 wrote:Run4Fun2009 wrote:packers21 wrote:I think Rugby needs some more representation.
Is it because they got 3 players named from a senior-laden team? Richland also has 3 players honored.
Alternates will dress one of the nights (if from the east...likely the night in Fargo; vice versa for west players).
I’m very surprised they get 3. Also look at the Region 7 Senior of the year not on the team and I’m very surprised. Then I look at the coaches and who would be on the committee and it makes sense.
The Schwab wrote:Gage Swanson is one of the twelve best class B seniors that play basketball. If the athlete is good enough to be selected for both teams then they should be selected for both teams and let the athlete make the choice.
The Schwab wrote:In this case, no it is not what happened.
Flying Wallenda wrote:A few thoughts:
1) 48 players picked and 27 alternates - 27!? What is the purpose of having 27 alternates? I know Run said that alternates dress one of the nights. When did that start to happen? Are they just on the bench - not allowed to play? Back in the day each team had 2 or 3 alternates - in case of an injury, suspension, etc. I'd like to hear the rational on having so many....
2) Has there every been 3 kids from one team on the lions team? If so I don't recall. Please don't take this as me slamming the kids from Rugby - they were a very very good team this year. Did they have 3 of the best 12 class b seniors in the state on their team? That's open for debate.
3) How exactly is this team picked? Do coaches nominate players followed by discussion - AKA fighting/debating who should be on vs. not? Who has the final say? I've always wondered....
Just as all-state, there are deserving kids left off every year, maybe at no fault of anyone. Looking forward to some clarity on my questions - THANKS in advance.
Flying Wallenda wrote:A few thoughts:
1) 48 players picked and 27 alternates - 27!? What is the purpose of having 27 alternates? I know Run said that alternates dress one of the nights. When did that start to happen? Are they just on the bench - not allowed to play? Back in the day each team had 2 or 3 alternates - in case of an injury, suspension, etc. I'd like to hear the rational on having so many....
2) Has there every been 3 kids from one team on the lions team? If so I don't recall. Please don't take this as me slamming the kids from Rugby - they were a very very good team this year. Did they have 3 of the best 12 class b seniors in the state on their team? That's open for debate.
3) How exactly is this team picked? Do coaches nominate players followed by discussion - AKA fighting/debating who should be on vs. not? Who has the final say? I've always wondered....
Just as all-state, there are deserving kids left off every year, maybe at no fault of anyone. Looking forward to some clarity on my questions - THANKS in advance.
BasketballMind wrote:Cannot believe we haven't heard from our Cavalier correspondent on this yet.
Bison-Vikes #1 wrote:Have remembered alternates all the way back to 1980, but as Flying Wallenda said, was normally only 2 or 3. There have been teams with multiple players nominated, but can't remember 3 seniors at the same time. North Star had 5 on one team and 3 on another, but weren't all seniors at the same time.
Run4Fun2009 wrote:2019 - Girls: Rugby had 3 girls
2015 - Boys: Rugby had 3 boys (1 alternate)
2015 - Girls: Bishop Ryan would have had 3 (https://www.minotdailynews.com/sports/s ... star-game/)
This is what I could find back to 2002...25 more years of info that I can't find online right now.
ndlionsfan wrote:Run4Fun2009 wrote:2019 - Girls: Rugby had 3 girls
2015 - Boys: Rugby had 3 boys (1 alternate)
2015 - Girls: Bishop Ryan would have had 3 (https://www.minotdailynews.com/sports/s ... star-game/)
This is what I could find back to 2002...25 more years of info that I can't find online right now.
Rugby must have had a pretty good rep in the past 5 years.
ndlionsfan wrote:Bison-Vikes #1 wrote:Have remembered alternates all the way back to 1980, but as Flying Wallenda said, was normally only 2 or 3. There have been teams with multiple players nominated, but can't remember 3 seniors at the same time. North Star had 5 on one team and 3 on another, but weren't all seniors at the same time.
Wouldn't they all have had to be seniors to be selected?
Return to Basketball - Class B
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 40 guests