Eminence wrote:I would agree with those picks.
Njos and Buck also had good years. Might substitute Buck for Messer just because Century took 5th but I do like the way Messer plays.
grlsbballfan wrote:I would agree with most of them but I think I would substitute Amy stroup from south instead of Paige Jenson. I no Miss jenson is a good player but the two stats are almost identical, and Amy is a senior and Paige is a Junior so you have to go with the senior.
grlsbballfan wrote:I think you go with the senior because her high school career is over and Paige has one more year to prove herself. It would be different if Paige stats blew Amy out of the water but they are almost the same.
balla45 wrote:grlsbballfan wrote:I think you go with the senior because her high school career is over and Paige has one more year to prove herself. It would be different if Paige stats blew Amy out of the water but they are almost the same.
If I was voting, I would just give it to both. Noone will comlain if there are 6 on the second team.
rep wrote:trust me. they will complain.
grlsbballfan wrote:I would agree with most of them but I think I would substitute Amy stroup from south instead of Paige Jenson. I no Miss jenson is a good player but the two stats are almost identical, and Amy is a senior and Paige is a Junior so you have to go with the senior.
balla45 wrote:rep wrote:trust me. they will complain.
I didn't state that a good way. Do you think there would be more complaints if one was left off or if an extra was added?
Baller wrote:grlsbballfan wrote:I would agree with most of them but I think I would substitute Amy stroup from south instead of Paige Jenson. I no Miss jenson is a good player but the two stats are almost identical, and Amy is a senior and Paige is a Junior so you have to go with the senior.
I think that Stroup is a good players, but you need to look at the fact that Jensen is the 3rd option on her team and put up those numbers and Stroup is the 1st option on hers.
balla45 wrote:grlsbballfan wrote:I think you go with the senior because her high school career is over and Paige has one more year to prove herself. It would be different if Paige stats blew Amy out of the water but they are almost the same.
If I was voting, I would just give it to both. Noone will comlain if there are 6 on the second team.
EastGuruWannabe wrote:its going to be hard for any girl from south to make all-state. not saying they're not deserving or are not one of the best players, but south was so balanced none of their stats stand out - at least scoring anyways. haring's steals, asts, and rebs are good. i disagree with the statement stroup was south's first option. i don't think they really had a "1st option" they freqeuntly had a different player lead them in scoring all season. i'd have to look it up, but i bet they had at least 6 different girls lead them in scoring this season at least once. the people who vote on it only look at stats. look at lexi braun. the talk above was about 1st option or 3rd option or whatever. lexi braun was the only option for wahpeton, thats why her scoring/rebounding are up. not saying shes not a good player, but put her on souths team or shanley or mandan, bis, etc - would she stand out as one of the best players in the state?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 13 guests