Page 4 of 5

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Tue Feb 19, 2008 7:50 pm
by Mr. Knowitall
Jamie Mauch of Hankinson is the best athlete in class B this year. A great football and basketball player. He also placed in state track&field.

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Wed Feb 20, 2008 1:24 pm
by digger
I agree that Mauch is probably right at the top, Class A or B. I just don't see how you can go with anyone but Zac Elgie however. They guy has done it in every sport he plays at the highest level for 3+ years. I was courtside at the state championship game against North his sophmore year. The battle he and Nathan Dehne (North's best athlete that year) had on both ends of the court was amazing. Dehne was a senior playing on one wheel, and Elgie as a sophmore was the heart of the Magi team. You could just tell Elgie was something special and he hasn't disapointed.

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Wed Feb 20, 2008 3:12 pm
by baseball
digger wrote:I agree that Mauch is probably right at the top, Class A or B. I just don't see how you can go with anyone but Zac Elgie however. They guy has done it in every sport he plays at the highest level for 3+ years. I was courtside at the state championship game against North his sophmore year. The battle he and Nathan Dehne (North's best athlete that year) had on both ends of the court was amazing. Dehne was a senior playing on one wheel, and Elgie as a sophmore was the heart of the Magi team. You could just tell Elgie was something special and he hasn't disapointed.


SOY Eric Erdmann??

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Wed Feb 20, 2008 3:49 pm
by digger
baseball wrote:
digger wrote:I agree that Mauch is probably right at the top, Class A or B. I just don't see how you can go with anyone but Zac Elgie however. They guy has done it in every sport he plays at the highest level for 3+ years. I was courtside at the state championship game against North his sophmore year. The battle he and Nathan Dehne (North's best athlete that year) had on both ends of the court was amazing. Dehne was a senior playing on one wheel, and Elgie as a sophmore was the heart of the Magi team. You could just tell Elgie was something special and he hasn't disapointed.


SOY Eric Erdmann??

Eric Erdmann was obviously North's best player, best in the state that year. Dehne was North High's best athlete, speed, strength, quickness, 6'2", a great competitor. Didn't mean to take anything away from Erdmann, he was terrific, having a nice career at Mary.

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Wed Feb 20, 2008 8:51 pm
by baseball
alright i get what your saying

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Sun Feb 24, 2008 2:23 pm
by Stormtrooper
digger wrote:I agree that Mauch is probably right at the top, Class A or B. I just don't see how you can go with anyone but Zac Elgie however. They guy has done it in every sport he plays at the highest level for 3+ years. I was courtside at the state championship game against North his sophmore year. The battle he and Nathan Dehne (North's best athlete that year) had on both ends of the court was amazing. Dehne was a senior playing on one wheel, and Elgie as a sophmore was the heart of the Magi team. You could just tell Elgie was something special and he hasn't disapointed.


how many state championship teams has elgie been on?

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Mon Feb 25, 2008 12:35 am
by smart source
Stormtrooper wrote:
digger wrote:I agree that Mauch is probably right at the top, Class A or B. I just don't see how you can go with anyone but Zac Elgie however. They guy has done it in every sport he plays at the highest level for 3+ years. I was courtside at the state championship game against North his sophmore year. The battle he and Nathan Dehne (North's best athlete that year) had on both ends of the court was amazing. Dehne was a senior playing on one wheel, and Elgie as a sophmore was the heart of the Magi team. You could just tell Elgie was something special and he hasn't disapointed.


how many state championship teams has elgie been on?[/quote

that would depend on what you include if you include summer ball starting at all star teams such as in call ripken then from cal ripken he would have been in 8 total winning 5 and if you just go from high school age and on it would be i think 5 total winning 3....i think also 8 west region championships from high school age on but those are both including legion baseball

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Thu Feb 28, 2008 8:38 pm
by Pdubs
The best all-around athlete in ND has to be Zach Wentz hands down.

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Mon Mar 03, 2008 1:09 am
by tjschobinger
What about Taylor Bruhschwein of DHS? been at state for tennis forever, started as a frosh for bball i believe, was on state record 4X400 relay team as a soph, took like 3rd in the 400 open at state last year, placed for hurdles, he placed in other sprints and sprint relays too but i just dont remember w/ very good accuracy..... and not to mention, last year at state track he felt like absolute crap the whole time..
what do you guys/ gals think?

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Mon Mar 03, 2008 7:23 pm
by i_see_it_all
tjschobinger wrote:What about Taylor Bruhschwein of DHS? been at state for tennis forever, started as a frosh for bball i believe, was on state record 4X400 relay team as a soph, took like 3rd in the 400 open at state last year, placed for hurdles, he placed in other sprints and sprint relays too but i just dont remember w/ very good accuracy..... and not to mention, last year at state track he felt like absolute crap the whole time..
what do you guys/ gals think?


im sure he's earned a lot of "participation" awards in his day. but im taking this post as someone trying to make a joke. the only reason im commenting on this is because i've always been impressed with the athletes the town of dickinson has put out over the years. that town always seems to have good teams (except in hockey, lol.)

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Mon Mar 03, 2008 8:21 pm
by balla45
i_see_it_all wrote:
tjschobinger wrote:What about Taylor Bruhschwein of DHS? been at state for tennis forever, started as a frosh for bball i believe, was on state record 4X400 relay team as a soph, took like 3rd in the 400 open at state last year, placed for hurdles, he placed in other sprints and sprint relays too but i just dont remember w/ very good accuracy..... and not to mention, last year at state track he felt like absolute crap the whole time..
what do you guys/ gals think?


im sure he's earned a lot of "participation" awards in his day. but im taking this post as someone trying to make a joke. the only reason im commenting on this is because i've always been impressed with the athletes the town of dickinson has put out over the years. that town always seems to have good teams (except in hockey, lol.)


How is Taylor Bruhschwein a joke? He is very good at tennis. He won state basketball as a junior, and is a 3 year starter, and the best shooter in the state. He is the number 1 seed in 300 hurdles, number 2 or 3 in the 400 meter dash, and he runs a leg on the 400 and state record holding 1600 relays.

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Mon Mar 03, 2008 11:43 pm
by tjschobinger
i_see_it_all wrote:
tjschobinger wrote:What about Taylor Bruhschwein of DHS? been at state for tennis forever, started as a frosh for bball i believe, was on state record 4X400 relay team as a soph, took like 3rd in the 400 open at state last year, placed for hurdles, he placed in other sprints and sprint relays too but i just dont remember w/ very good accuracy..... and not to mention, last year at state track he felt like absolute crap the whole time..
what do you guys/ gals think?


im sure he's earned a lot of "participation" awards in his day. but im taking this post as someone trying to make a joke. the only reason im commenting on this is because i've always been impressed with the athletes the town of dickinson has put out over the years. that town always seems to have good teams (except in hockey, lol.)



WHAT? you cant be serious right now... im not even kidding, he's one of the best athletes in the state. If you haven't heard of him you're oviously not on top of things when it comes to North Dakota sports/academics anyways. hh, if you call being a crucial part of a couple state championship teams "participation" awards,, then yea, i guess he's won a few. i can be alright with you not agreeing,,,, but saying that he's a joke? thats just not right.

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Tue Mar 04, 2008 6:51 am
by NDSportsFan
ok ok, let's respect others opinions, even if we don't agree.

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Wed Mar 05, 2008 1:52 am
by demon_fan14
I think Ethan Kline deserves to be in this topic.......extremely athletic

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 12:03 am
by theDIRTYdub
what about Patrick Wolf of new town, ND? The Kid is the 2 time state cross country champion, he dominates every year in state in most events (3200, 1600, 3200 relays, 800, could run 400) he is an all region basketball player with plenty of game, and he played football when he was a junior but due to chance of injury for track or basketball decided to stay out and rightfully so, he has options to run all over including but not limited to schools like minnesota.

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 9:56 am
by billy
In the Track and Field board I believe someone said that Patrick Wolf broke his ankle playing in a basketball tournament. That is a shame considering how good he is in the distance events.

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Wed Apr 23, 2008 10:31 am
by track guy
I believe Zach Wentz is the best athlete in the state. First team all state for football, one of the best pitchers in the state, if not the best. This kid is just a stud. He will be a great addition to NDSU's football and baseball team.

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Wed Apr 23, 2008 3:19 pm
by D-Pain
track guy wrote:I believe Zach Wentz is the best athlete in the state. First team all state for football, one of the best pitchers in the state, if not the best. This kid is just a stud. He will be a great addition to NDSU's football and baseball team.


He is pretty good too but dont forget about zach elgie.

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Wed Apr 23, 2008 10:32 pm
by janobilly20
zach wentz

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Thu Apr 24, 2008 11:14 am
by D-Pain
janobilly20 wrote:zach wentz


Yes but you are forgetting that Elgie is getting a scholarship to go to Kansas and Wentz is walking on at NDSU. They are both decent athletes though...

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Thu Apr 24, 2008 7:05 pm
by janobilly20
D-Pain wrote:
janobilly20 wrote:zach wentz


Yes but you are forgetting that Elgie is getting a scholarship to go to Kansas and Wentz is walking on at NDSU. They are both decent athletes though...


actually, no i am not forgetting about that. you are forgetting that wentz is trying out both baseball and football, and he is better in both

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Thu Apr 24, 2008 7:23 pm
by D-Pain
janobilly20 wrote:
D-Pain wrote:
janobilly20 wrote:zach wentz


Yes but you are forgetting that Elgie is getting a scholarship to go to Kansas and Wentz is walking on at NDSU. They are both decent athletes though...


actually, no i am not forgetting about that. you are forgetting that wentz is trying out both baseball and football, and he is better in both


No, im not forgetting about that either. Elgie was the west region football player of the year and is a great basketball player, not to mention his best sport...Baseball. No offense to wentz, but what did he do this winter? Oh yeah....NOTHING! This is a thread about athletes and not people who pick and choose when they want to play. Try to keep your Century jaundice point of view away from ND preps. Thx.

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Thu Apr 24, 2008 7:47 pm
by Hinsa
Lighten up D-pain. People are entitled to their opinions. That's what this forum is all about. We're all jaundiced towards our home teams.

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Thu Apr 24, 2008 8:12 pm
by janobilly20
D-Pain wrote:
janobilly20 wrote:
D-Pain wrote:
janobilly20 wrote:zach wentz


Yes but you are forgetting that Elgie is getting a scholarship to go to Kansas and Wentz is walking on at NDSU. They are both decent athletes though...


actually, no i am not forgetting about that. you are forgetting that wentz is trying out both baseball and football, and he is better in both


No, im not forgetting about that either. Elgie was the west region football player of the year and is a great basketball player, not to mention his best sport...Baseball. No offense to wentz, but what did he do this winter? Oh yeah....NOTHING! This is a thread about athletes and not people who pick and choose when they want to play. Try to keep your Century jaundice point of view away from ND preps. Thx.


uhh he only lifted, look at wentz' football stats to elgies....they're twice as better if not more. and i believe in baseball the other day, wentz' struck out elgie twice...good way to prepare for kansas, and the only reason wentz didnt play hockey like he did his sophomore year is so he doesnt injure is ACL again. why not concentrate on the sports he's going to do and not risk injury? plus wentz doesnt cry and whine like elgie does in every game he plays, hes an athlete that respects his opponents and is classy. so try to keep your minot jaundice point of view away from ND preps.

Re: BEST ALL-AROUND ATHLETE IN NORTH DAKOTA?

PostPosted: Thu Apr 24, 2008 8:26 pm
by NDSportsFan
How about we throw some props out to our boys and still respect others opinions? That's what ND preps is about.